New Evidence of the Usefulness of Real-Time Sentiment Indices in Econometric and Judgement-Based Forecasting Models
Job Market Paper · Journal Submitted · 2026
Abstract +
In this paper we construct a set of new narrative sentiment indices using textual data from a large corpus of U.S. economic and policy documents. The indices are designed for use in real-time forecasting contexts and are constructed using transformer-based language models and LLM-assisted annotation. They include a finance-domain transformer; an economics-tone model trained on LLM-generated annotations of Federal Reserve, BLS, and Census text; and a topic-conditioned narrative measure.
To determine the usefulness of these three indices for forecasting, we carry out a series of experiments in which their marginal predictive content is assessed. We first assess the predictive content of the indices in econometric models used for real-time U.S. macroeconomic and financial forecasting. We then assess whether our sentiment indices contain information that can be utilized to improve the quasi-judgemental forecasts reported in the United States Survey of Professional Forecasters (SPF). This is done by testing the rationality of SPF forecasts when conditioning on both real-time macroeconomic variables and our sentiment indices.
In the real-time forecasting experiment, the autoregressive benchmark attains the lowest mean square forecast error in 11 of 44 target-variable and forecast-horizon cases, while one of the eleven alternative models attains the lowest mean square forecast error in the remaining 33 cases. Among these 33 cases, 31 involve specifications containing at least one sentiment index and two involve the macroeconomic-variable-only specification. In addition, we find that SPF forecasts incorporate the information contained in our three contemporaneous economic narrative indices, but do not incorporate the information contained in two widely used consumer-sentiment survey indices. Thus, real-time econometric forecasts can be made more accurate by incorporating information from our new narrative indices, while judgemental forecasts can be made more accurate by utilizing information available in consumer sentiment indices, but not by utilizing information available in our new narrative sentiment indices.